I’m *finally* getting around to reading this series, after my writer friend and my book-loving sister both recommended it to me several months ago. So far I’ve read the first two books, and I’m totally into it. With a few caveats, that is. (Please note–the review for Scarlet contains spoilers for Cinder.)
My main problem with this book is that by page 115, I knew what the plot twist was going to be. The story was a bit predictable, and I wanted more from Cinder based on how many good things I’d heard about it. But that didn’t keep me from enjoying the story and the characters.
Cinder is a futuristic dystopian fairy tale retelling set in Asia, in which Cinderella is a cyborg, immune to the deadly plague that is sweeping the world and good at mechanics. Cinder does her best to hide her cyborg parts, as there is a lot of prejudice against cyborgs. They are looked down on and forced to be guinea pigs for the plague antidote–as they have already had a second chance at life, many people see that as only fair.
Throughout the book, the POV switches between Cinder and Prince Kai. Cinder meets the prince well before the ball when he hires her to fix one of his robots (nope, can’t remember the word they use in the book, so I’m going with robot). Prince Kai, whose father is on the brink of death from the plague, is carrying the weight of a potential war with the Lunar people on his shoulders–a people who can brainwash others by manipulating their brain waves, and whose evil queen will only be satisfied when she can marry Prince Kai and begin to take over the earth.
This book is an easy read. The descriptions of this futuristic, dystopian world create the setting without being overly detailed or intrusive. Little details tie the story to the original Cinderella–like Cinder’s tiny cyborg foot, and the orange car she takes to the ball. The writing is interesting and snappy, and the internal fight at the end made it all worth it. (And I must say, I *love* the lie detector in Cinder’s retinal display. It was my favorite cyborg modification.) On the whole, despite some predictability in the plot twists, I really enjoyed the characters and the setting. I’m excited to see where the series goes from here.
Unfortunately, I disliked this book a lot more than Cinder, mainly because I didn’t connect with Scarlet’s character at all. Her story is, of course, a retelling of Little Red Riding Hood, and unlike Cinder’s retelling, this one is a lot more heavy-handed. Scarlet herself is a lot more stereotypical than Cinder was–she’s just a girl living in the French countryside with her grandmother, who is impulsive and gets into a rescue mission with a mysterious, possibly dangerous man she barely knows. Her romance (with this mysterious man, of course) was well built up, but very tortured souls and a little Twilight. Not nearly as satisfying as Cinder’s short-lived romance with Kai.
I like Cinder so much more than Scarlet–I’m really glad Cinder is in this book. Sections of the book alternate between telling Scarlet’s story and filling us in on what Cinder is doing. Cinder, who was (*spoiler for book 1*) put in jail at the end of the last book, breaks out with the help of another inmate, who fortunately owns a ship they use to get away. I love seeing Cinder’s struggle with her new-found Lunar powers–she uses them, but she hates how easy it is for her. Plus, Cinder’s memories coming back = awesome! Overall, her sections are much stronger and more interesting than Scarlet’s, and I found myself wishing this book was mostly about Cinder, rather than Scarlet.
Unlike the last book, there was one twist in Scarlet I didn’t see coming, and it made me gasp out loud. Loved it! Despite the flaws in both of these books, they really are interesting, fun reads, and I’m definitely looking forward to the next two books.
Rating: Pretty Darn Good